| Platinum | IL Terrazzo Ristorante |
| Gold | Wild Mountain |
| Silver | Deep Cove Chalet |
| Bronze | IL Covo Trattoria |
| Top Pick | Blue Crab Seafood House |
| Top Pick | Cafe Brio |
| Top Pick | Ithaka Greek Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Marilena Cafe & Raw Bar |
| Top Pick | Victoria Harbour House Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Vista 18 Restaurant + Lounge |