| Platinum | Red Fish Blue Fish |
| Gold | Nautical Nellies Steak & Seafood House |
| Silver | Barb's Fish & Chips |
| Bronze | Marilena Cafe & Raw Bar |
| Top Pick | Blue Crab Seafood House |
| Top Pick | Ferris' Grill & Garden Patio |
| Top Pick | Oak Bay Seafood |
| Top Pick | The Flying Otter Grill |
| Top Pick | The Japanese Village Restaurant |
| Top Pick | The Wandering Mollusk |