| Platinum | Parachute Ice Cream |
| Gold | Cold Comfort Icecream |
| Silver | Beacon Drive In Restaurant |
| Bronze | 49 Below |
| Top Pick | A LA Mode Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Ice Cream Mountain |
| Top Pick | Lexi's Ice Cream and Treats |
| Top Pick | Lexis Ice Cream Treats |
| Top Pick | MR Tubbs Ice Cream Parlor |
| Top Pick | Sub-Zero Ice Cream |