| Platinum | Red Barn Market |
| Gold | Italian Food Imports |
| Silver | Fig Delicatessen |
| Bronze | Lock, Stock and Bagel |
| Top Pick | Dutch Bakery & Diner |
| Top Pick | Fairway Market - Sidney by the Sea |
| Top Pick | Ottavio Italian Bakery & Delicatessen Cafe |
| Top Pick | Soupa Cafe |
| Top Pick | Thrifty Foods |
| Top Pick | Tonollis Deli |