| Platinum | Peninsula Pizza |
| Gold | Virtuous Pie |
| Silver | Romeo's Pizza |
| Bronze | My-Chosen Pizza |
| Top Pick | 900 Degrees Pizza |
| Top Pick | Fernwood Pizza Company |
| Top Pick | Mariners Pizza |
| Top Pick | Oregano's Pizza and Bistro |
| Top Pick | Panago Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pizzeria Prima Strada |